Atheist Knows How God Would Act If He Did Exist

Atheist Knows How God Would Act If He Did Exist – Ep.351 – The Great Debate – Stein’s 2nd Opening – Part 2

Patrick December 15, 2025

Throughout this second part of Stein’s opening, he shows himself to be an atheist who doesn’t believe in God but definitively knows how that god would act if he did exist. Stein attempts to conflate logical contradiction with a psychological ickiness he perceives in the argument for God. Suffering, evil, justice, and how to act are things Stein knows how his made up god would act – a weird thing for someone who claims that he just lacks a belief.

TIMELINE:

00:00 – Introduction
02:10 – All God Has To Do Is Appear To A Group Of People For Stein To Believe
06:14 – Stein Is Just Using His Unargued Presuppositions
10:00 – Stein Thinks He His god Wouldn’t Allow Suffering
12:48 – Stein Doesn’t Provide His Basis For Evil Or Good Or Logic
17:04 – Stein Doesn’t Think Sin Or Justice Is Fair
20:55 – Stein Doesn’t Believe In God Because Of Religious Pluralism
21:44 – Stein Sees Christianity As A Failure Because Christians Can Be Bad
24:06 – Stein Should Ask These Questions To A Christian
27:52 – What Does Stein Think He’s Left With?
29:33 – Conclusion

If He Did Exist